Sunday, November 06, 2022

The percentage of 25-54 year-olds employed fell in October 0.4 percentage points after falling 0.1 percentage points in September-How has the economy done in the past after a sequence like that?

There have not been many sequences of a 0.1 fall followed by a 0.4 fall, so I also looked at cases when a 0.3 decline was preceded by either a 0.1 or 0.2 fall. Since 1948 there have been 8 cases and generally the economy has not done well after any of them (this is related to the previous post which has a link to the BLS data). 

But one caveat is that things tended to be declining over the prior 6 months for each case. So it makes sense that the economy might keep declining or be sluggish afterwards. The two month sequence I look at might not tell the whole story.

The table below presents the data. Take the Dec.-Nov. 1981 case. It fell 0.1 in Nov. and then 0.4 in Dec. This is indicated in the "Change" column.

The "Previous Month's %" shows 74.5, meaning that 74.5% of 25-54 year-olds were employed in Oct. of 1981. It took 23 months until we got back to at least 74.5% and in the mean time, it fell to as low as 72.6% (the "Lowest intervening % column).

But over the previous 6 months it had gone down 0.6 (see the last column of the table). So the economy was already weak. In 6 of the 8 cases it did go down over the 6 preceding months.

In the two cases when it went up over the previous 6 months, things were still not good afterwards. In the March-April 1980 case it took 14 months to recover with drop of 1.1 from the starting point to the lowest point.

In the July-Aug 1959 case, it took 10 months to recover with maximum decrease of 0.9 (and the economy had been doing well in the previous 6 months with the % of 25-54 year-olds employed going up 1.0).

The Oct-Nov 1974 case saw previous 6 month decline of just 0.1. So things were really not too bad in the run up yet recovery still took 23 months and the decline from the starting point was 1.9.

So there is some cause for concern. But our current case was preceded by a six month gain of 0.8. So maybe that indicates some underlying strength that some of the earlier cases did not have (although, again, look at the 1959 case when it went up 1.0 over the previous 6 months).

Of course, each case might have unique features or variables that make any projections for the current case difficult.

One thing to remember is that we have not recovered from the Covid decline. It was 80.5% before Covid and got up to 80.3% before falling to 79.8% with the declines the last two months (the Covid low was 69.6%). It is disappointing to get close to full recovery only to start falling back.

Month/Year

Change

Previous Month's %

Months to equal or exceed

Lowest Intervening %

Previous 6 Month Change

2022 Oct

-0.4

 

 

 

 

2022 Sept

-0.1

80.3

?

?

0.8

1981 Dec

-0.4

 

 

 

 

1981 Nov

-0.1

74.5

23

72.6

-0.6

1959 Aug

-0.4

 

 

 

 

1959 July

-0.1

66.1

10

65.2

1.0

 

 

 

 

 

 

2001 Aug

-0.3

 

 

 

 

2001 July

-0.1

80.6

Never

 

-0.8

1981 Sept

-0.3

 

 

 

 

1981 Aug

-0.1

74.8

29

72.6

-0.9

1980 April

-0.3

 

 

 

 

1980 March

-0.2

75

14

73.9

0.1

1974 Nov

-0.3

 

 

 

 

1974 Oct

-0.1

70.8

23

68.9

-0.1

1970 Sept

-0.3

 

 

 

 

1970 Aug

-0.1

69.6

20

68.8

-0.6

1949 April

-0.3

 

 

 

 

1949 March

-0.1

62.6

15

61.3

-0.4



Friday, November 04, 2022

The percentage of 25-54 year-olds employed fell in October (and it fell in Sept. for the first back-to-back declines since the Covid pandemic started)

One weakness of the unemployment rate is that if people drop out of the labor force they cannot be counted as an unemployed person and the unemployment rate goes down. They are no longer actively seeking work and it might be because they are discouraged workers. The lower unemployment rate can be misleading in this case. People dropping out of the labor force might indicate a weak labor market.

We could look at the employment to population ratio instead, since that includes those not in the labor force. But that includes everyone over 16 and that means that senior citizens are in the group but many of them have retired. The more that retire, the lower this ratio would be and that might be misleading. It would not necessarily mean the labor market is weak.

But we have this ratio for people age 25-54 (which also eliminates many college age people who might not be looking for work).

The percentage of 25-54 year olds employed was 79.8% in Oct. and 80.2% in Sept. It was 80.3% in August.  The last time it fell two straight months was in March and April of 2020 when the pandemic started.

It was 80.5% in Jan. 2020 and 69.6% in April 2020.  Click here to see the BLS data. The unemployment rate was 3.7% in October (it was 3.5% in Sept.). Click here to go to that data. The % of those 16 and older employed went from 60.12%% in Sept. to 59.96%% in Oct.

Here is a good graph from the St. Louis Fed. It shows that there are 127,138,000 people in the 25-54 year old group. So since we are 0.7 percentage point below the 80.5% of Jan. 2020 (the high point since the previous recession), that is still 889,966 fewer jobs (Hat tip: Vance Ginn of the Texas Public Policy Foundation). 

Also, we are up 10.2 percentage points since April 2020 (79.8 - 69.6). That is 93.6% of what we lost from Jan. 2020 to April 2020 (10.9 percentage points or 80.5 - 69.6). Then 10.2/10.9 = 93.6%. So we have gotten about 93.6% of the jobs back (but again, we have lost some in the last month).  

Here is the timeline graph of the percentage of 25-54 year olds employed since 2012.


Now since 1948  

Thursday, November 03, 2022

One paper says studying economics does not make you more selfish and another says it does

The first paper says no.

From UMass Amherst.

"Working Paper Number

2021-07

Publication Date

2021

Abstract

It is widely held that studying economics makes you more selfish and politically conservative. We use a difference-in-differences strategy to disentangle the causal impact of economics education from selection effects. We estimate the effect of four different intermediate microeconomics courses on students’ experimentally elicited social preferences and beliefs about others, and policy opinions. We find no discernible effect of studying economics (whatever the course content) on self-interest or beliefs about others’ self-interest. Results on policy preferences also point to little effect, except that economics may make students somewhat less opposed to highly restrictive immigration policies.

License

UMass Amherst Open Access Policy

Recommended Citation

Girardi, Daniele; Madhurika Mamunuru, Sai; Halliday, Simon D.; and Bowles, Samuel, "Does Economics Make You Selfish?" (2021). Economics Department Working Paper Series. 304.
Retrieved from https://scholarworks.umass.edu/econ_workingpaper/304"

This paper says yes. Isolating nature from nurture: Does exposure to business and economics education make students more selfinterested? by Mattias Sundemo and Åsa Löfgren of The University of Gothenburg.

"Does exposure to business and economics education make students more self-interested and less interested in a career that would contribute to a better society? Using a panel dataset of more than 900 individuals from a European Business School we are able to isolate the role of self-selection from possible education or nurture-effects on prosocial (altruistic) values and attitudes associated with exposure to business and economics education. The school in this study, as well as many other contemporary business schools in this part of the world, have for many years integrated issues of sustainability, responsibility and ethics into their business and economics education. Still, after all these efforts, our results indicate that business and economics students become significantly less prosocial during their program studies, and importantly, we find no such effect among students from other disciplines. Further, we find that prosocial attitudes significantly correlate with prosocial behavior (measured by donation in an incentivized charity dictator game). We also provide evidence for highly heterogeneous effects with regards to majors (accounting, management, finance, economics etc.). Finally, we find notable and significant gender differences that largely persist throughout university education."